FAIR USE NOTICE

FAIR USE NOTICE

A BEAR MARKET ECONOMICS BLOG

OCCUPY POLITICALLY

This site may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in an effort to advance understanding of environmental, political, human rights, economic, democracy, scientific, and social justice issues, etc. we believe this constitutes a ‘fair use’ of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law.

In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml

If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond ‘fair use’, you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

FAIR USE NOTICE FAIR USE NOTICE: This page may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. This website distributes this material without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for scientific, research and educational purposes. We believe this constitutes a fair use of any such copyrighted material as provided for in 17 U.S.C § 107.

Read more at: http://www.etupdates.com/fair-use-notice/#.UpzWQRL3l5M | ET. Updates
FAIR USE NOTICE FAIR USE NOTICE: This page may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. This website distributes this material without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for scientific, research and educational purposes. We believe this constitutes a fair use of any such copyrighted material as provided for in 17 U.S.C § 107.

Read more at: http://www.etupdates.com/fair-use-notice/#.UpzWQRL3l5M | ET. Updates

All Blogs licensed under Creative Commons Attribution 3.0

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License.

Thursday, September 3, 2015

The Republicans Lie – About Everything


PoliticusUSA



The Republicans Lie – About Everything

facebook_1405979906057
Republican dishonesty, not only about what they do and what they would like to do, but about the world we live in, are endemic. And the situation is getting steadily worse as Republicans daily seem more unhinged, leaving liberals and progressives shaking their heads in dismay.

Do you remember last year when Public Policy Polling revealed that more Louisiana Republicans blame President Obama for the mishandling of Katrina relief efforts than blame President Bush? It is a matter of public record that Barack Obama was only a freshman senator then, while Bush had been president for half a decade. Almost half of Louisiana Republicans didn’t know who to blame.

Of course, Republicans have also blamed Obama for the Iraq War and routinely pretend that there were no terrorist attacks on U.S. soil while Bush was president (9/11 anyone?). Not only that, but Fox News has excised any subsequent Bush-era terrorist attacks from public memory. Republicans have also conveniently forgotten that Bush presided over the economic collapse of 2008. Obama wasn’t elected until November 4 of that year and did not take office until the following January.

Of course, President Obama is currently being blamed for the immigration crisis at the border that Republicans are responsible for. Bush signed the law; Obama gets blamed.


Republican_Talking_Point

Republicans attack President Obama for taking too many vacation days. In reality, as Al Sharpton pointed out on August 9, 2013,
[Obama] has taken 92 days of vacation since he was sworn in. How many did President (George W.) Bush take by the same point in his presidency? Three hundred and sixty seven. Yes, more than a full year of vacation.
PolitiFact has rated this statement “mostly true” in that Bush spent some working vacation days at his Texas ranch. I remember Bush being on vacation all the time; Republicans don’t even remember Bush.

Republicans want to sue and impeach President Obama for signing executive orders, even though he has issued far fewer executive orders than President Bush, whose executive orders were not the object of Republican complaint.

For example, on September 25, 2012, FactCheck.org pointed out that “Obama has issued 139 executive orders as of Sept. 25 [2012]…Bush issued 160 executive orders through Sept. 20, 2004, a comparable amount of time.”

As of June 20, 2014, Obama had signed 182 executive orders. Bush signed 173 in his first term alone, and 291 during his entire presidency.

Again, if you want to count executive orders you can do so; it’s a matter of public record and the University of California Santa Barbara helpfully tracks them by year and president. Republicans prefer just making stuff up because the facts do not agree with the fantasies they want to push.

Republicans have claimed Obama is adding to the deficit (while they add to it themselves via tax breaks for their rich owners) when in fact he has been steadily reducing the deficit. In fact, last year, Obama shrank the deficit to a 5-year low. And as Paul Krugman points out, there was never a crisis in the first place. As with all their other scandals, it was manufactured by conservatives to advance their anti-Social Security and Medicare agenda.

Democrats like to believe that when they engage the Right in debate that they do so on more or less equal terms. Both sides are, after all, comprised of sentient human beings. But Republicans have given substance to the old childhood taunt, “I am rubber, you are glue, words bounce off me and stick to you.”

They are literally impervious to facts.

And not only is President Obama magically to blame for all Bush’s manifest misdeeds, he is somehow also to blame for every misdeed committed anywhere in the world.

Everything that happens is somehow Obama’s fault and John McCain has turned himself into Chuck Norris, able to strangle the butterfly that flapped its wings in Siberia to prevent a typhoon hitting the West Coast. Only John McCain, who voted for the Iraq War, could have stopped the Iraq War.

This must make sense only to Republicans, who nod their heads sagely.

If only they could do so in strait jackets, which is arguably where they belong.

Republicans live in a world where women’s bodies magically repel unwanted sperm and where some equally mysterious alchemy turns sperm in the anus into the AIDS virus, where such a thing as “legitimate rape” exists and global warming and evolution do not. This is a world where slavery really wasn’t so bad and anyway, whites were the real victims, apparently moping about and wishing they could be slaves too.

And what do you say to egregious and sustained Republican insistence that racism is a distant memory, or that women have attained equality of pay with men? Of all people, Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-SC) has no right to call a Democrat delusional, not when the platform and ideology of his party is completely founded on delusion.

Tough to tell if any of those things are crazier than creationist Ken Ham calling for an end to the space program because any aliens we find are going to hell anyway, as though the Space Program was ever a proselytizing effort. In the end, how does one compare and rate samples of excrement? Ham’s real problem is that if the space program continues, we are almost certain to find life on another world – and sooner rather than later – thus bringing his creationist fantasy down around his ears.

This is a world where Kirk Cameron knows more than Stephen Hawking, where he and others can throw stones even while complaining they are being stoned. I could go on, but this article would never end, because, by myself, I can’t keep up with the fast and furious flow of Republican mendacity.

Far from creating a straw man, Republicans have created a straw country, one where nothing is as it seems, one that has no relationship – not even a passing resemblance – to the actual fact-based world in which we live. In short, Republicans lie. They lie about everything. They even lie about lying.

The world laughs. The Democrats – and the American people – are left holding the bag.

Friday, July 24, 2015

ALEC's Scary Corporate Agenda: 7 of Its Most Anti-Democratic and Science-Denying Ideas




Economy

ALEC's annual gathering revealed how right-wingers will push dangerous legislation across the country. 

 
 

Photo Credit: http://www.prwatch.org


Starting Wednesday this week, the right-wing American Legislative Exchange Council, or "ALEC," will bring together hundreds of corporate lobbyists with state and local politicians at a posh hotel in San Diego for the group's annual meeting.

Republican presidential candidate and ALEC alum Scott Walker, who has signed over 20 ALEC bills into law, will address this month's meeting, as well as 2016 GOP presidential hopefuls Mike Huckabee and Ted Cruz, who participated in ALEC meetings before he joined the U.S. Senate.

Protesters are planning on bringing a little transparency to the proceedings, by welcoming the candidates and ALEC participants on July 22.

ALEC, which drafts and markets model bills for legislators, has had a mixed year. Over a dozen companies, including tech giants Google and Facebook, stopped funding the group over its role in promoting climate change denial, yet after the 2014 elections gave Republicans control of 68 out of 98 state legislative bodies, some states have had few impediments to the corporate-friendly legislation that ALEC peddles.

For example, in just the first half of 2015, Wisconsin became a "right to work" state and repealed the prevailing wage, another pro-union law; Michigan blocked local control over minimum wage and paid sick days; and Texas banned cities from regulating fracking.

A look at the San Diego ALEC agenda tells us more about what ALEC has planned for 2015 and beyond. Here are seven major initiatives that the right-wing group seeks to impose on America.

1. Attack Federal Efforts to Rein in Carbon Pollution

Even though California is suffering from a historic drought, the climate change deniers on the Environment and Agriculture Task Force will be working on new ways to stymie action addressing carbon emissions.

In recent years, ALEC has targeted the Environmental Protection Agency's "Clean Power Plan," which is a set of rules limiting carbon dioxide pollution from coal plants. At the behest of its funders like Koch Industries, Peabody Energy, and American Electric Power, ALEC has been organizing a state-level campaign against the rules: the group organized legislators to press their state attorneys general into joining litigation backed by the energy industry that challenges the regulations, adopted a model resolution attacking the plan, and last December adopted a model bill that would create new hurdles for the Plan's implementation.

At this month's meeting, the Energy, Environment, and Agriculture Task Force--which is chaired by American Electric Power-- will consider a "State Power Accountability and Reliability Charter (SPARC)," which seeks to undermine the Clean Power Plan by declaring that state agencies cannot implement it. And, the task force's "Energy Subcommittee" will hold a discussion on "State Responses to EPA’s Proposed Clean Power Plan."
Another model bill on the ALEC agenda is the "Environmental Impact Litigation Act," which effectively allows corporate interests to hire a state's Department of Justice as their own private attorneys. The bill creates a corporate-backed fund for states to sue over federal environmental laws--such as the EPA's Clean Power Plan--guided by an "environmental impact litigation advisory committee" made up of political appointees and representatives of "individuals representing agriculture and energy trade commissions."

2. Undermining Renewable Energy

ALEC will also double-down on its attacks on rooftop solar and renewable energy.

For the last few years, ALEC and funders like Edison Electric Energy have promoted bills to repeal state Renewable Portfolio Standards, which require utilities to provide some power from renewable sources. Despite support from the Kochs' Americans for Prosperity, ALEC has had limited success in pushing these bills into law, so the group is looking for new ways to undermine renewable standards.

The latest effort is called an "Act Providing Incentives for Carbon Reduction Investments." The industry-friendly bill would free utilities from the requirement that they produce more energy from renewable sources, as long as they claim to make "carbon reduction investments"--which includes controversial programs like carbon sequestration, or campaigns to encourage consumers to reduce energy use. This would undermine the purpose of the renewable standards, which is to promote a shift to renewable energy.

3. Thwart Rooftop Solar

Solar will also be on the agenda. ALEC has tried in a variety of ways to reduce incentives for individuals and businesses to build rooftop solar panels by raising the costs. Over the last few years, ALEC and its utility industry funders have promoted bills to eliminate "net metering," which gives solar users a credit for excess energy they feed back into the grid, and have been behind efforts to impose a surcharge on rooftop solar users. With few exceptions, these efforts have failed, thanks to strong support for solar from conservatives who like the self-sufficiency that rooftop solar provides, and the fact that in many states the solar industry is creating manufacturing and construction jobs.
In San Diego, ALEC will consider a proposal called a "Resolution Concerning Special Markets for Direct Solar Power Sales" that aims to prop-up the monopolies enjoyed by traditional utilities and oppose direct-to-consumer solar sales. It will be coupled with a presentation called "Consumer Protection Concerns Surround Rooftop Solar Model Policy." In many states, solar developers are allowed to install panels on a customer's home or business for free, then sell the power directly to the consumer, rather than through a monopoly utility provider like Peabody Energy.

Direct-to-consumer energy sales that bypass heavily-regulated monopoly utilities might be viewed as the sort of "market disruption" that free market adherents claim to support. After all, ALEC has celebrated the emergence of ride-sharing companies like Uber because they disrupt taxi monopolies and allow direct-to-consumer ride sales.

The key difference is that ALEC is bankrolled by utility companies. ALEC funders like Peabody Energy, Duke Energy, and Murray Energy are not pleased about the threat to profits posed by direct-to-consumer solar, so therefore it must be crushed, free market principles be damned. Incredibly, the "Resolution Concerning Special Markets for Direct Solar Power Sales" declares that direct-to-consumer solar is "antithetical to free markets."
The proposal appears to come from the climate change deniers at the Heartland Institute.

4."Beepocalypse Not"

At this meeting, ALEC is denying more than climate change. It also is apparently denying the mass die-off of bees, which threatens food supplies--two-thirds of crops require bee pollination--and which scientists have linked to type of insecticide produced by ALEC member Bayer and other companies. Until recently, Bayer had a representative on ALEC's corporate board and has been listed as the ALEC corporate co-chair in states like Massachusetts, Nevada, Pennsylvania, South Dakota, and Texas.

Bayer has been actively pushing back on the notion that its products contribute to a bee colony collapse. According to a report from Friends of the Earth, Bayer recently launched a "Bee Care Tour” as well as a children’s book "in which a friendly neighborhood beekeeper tells young Toby that the bees are getting sick, but 'not to worry' it's just a problem with mites, and there is special medicine to make bees healthy"--medicine that Bayer produces, of course.

At this month's ALEC meeting, bee die-off denialists took a clumsy stab at being clever: in an apparent reference to "Apocalypse Now" (or perhaps Wayne's World), they titled their presentation, "'Beepocalypse Not."

5. Preemption Hypocrisy

ALEC's new offshoot focused on local government, the American City County Exchange (ACCE), will also meet in San Diego.

Local democracy has led to some significant policy wins in recent years, with cities like Philadelphia guaranteeing workers paid sick days, and places like Denton, Texas banning fracking. ALEC's response to cities and counties acting as laboratories of democracy has traditionally been to crush it, through state "preemption" laws that prohibit local governments from raising the minimum wage, or regulating GMOs, or building municipal broadband.

With ACCE, ALEC and its corporate backers are taking the fight directly to the local level, urging city and county officials on the one hand to give up their authority to protect the health and economic well-being of their constituents, and on the other to push policy measures to advance corporate interests.​

The biggest proactive ACCE initiative is a push for local right to work laws. In the months following a local right to work workshop at ACCE’s meeting last December, twelve Kentucky counties have enacted the anti-union measures, and similar proposals have been floated in states like Illinois and Pennsylvania. But enacting right to work on the local level likely violates federal law, so groups like the Koch-backed Americans for Prosperity and the state Chamber of Commerce are bankrolling the legal defense of counties that get sued.

Local right to work is again on the ACCE agenda for this month's meeting, with the group expected to officially adopt a Local Right to Work model bill.
It will also hold a workshop aimed a propping up another ACCE funder, the payday loan industry: the presentation is titled "Payday Loans; 'Local Free Market Solutions for a Difficult Policy Problem.'”

Besides pushing policy measures that advance the interests of ACCE's funders, ACCE is also urging local electeds to accept state preemption laws.

In a workshop titled “Understanding State Preemption Laws," ALEC and ACCE will pitch local officials on why they should let state legislatures steamroll their authority to protect the health and economic well-being of their constituents. The workshop will be moderated by Libby Szabo, a former Colorado state legislator and ALEC state chair who is now a local official: she resigned from the state legislature just two months after winning reelection to take a county commissioner appointment, leading to charges from the editorial board of the conservative Denver Post that she was "thumbing her nose at voters."

The lesson here is that ALEC supports local control when it advances the interests of its funders, yet actively works to undermine local democracy when it threatens corporate profits.

ALEC's hypocrisy around the idea "government that is closest to the people governs best" isn't just limited to city-state relations. Even though ALEC has fought federal policies like healthcare reform and the Environmental Protection Agency’s regulation of carbon emissions under the guise of “state’s rights,” at this month's meeting it will push policies that run contrary even to that notion. Here again, corporate profits trump anything resembling principles.

ALEC will hold a workshop telling state legislators that they should embrace federal preemption of state chemical regulation, which happens to benefit ALEC funders like the American Chemistry Council. The "Environmental Health and Regulation Subcommittee" will hold a presentation titled "Supporting Chemical Regulation Preemption Supports Manufacturing," where legislators will apparently be told it is just swell that the federal Toxic Substances Control Act will prohibit states from enacting tougher chemical regulations.

And, the Tax and Fiscal Policy Task Force will consider a proposed "Resolution Urging Congress to Eliminate Discriminatory State and Local Taxes on Automobile Renters," which calls on Congress to preempt discriminatory state and local taxes on car rentals. It is hard to imagine a more blatant piece of corporate-friendly legislation, yet ALEC continues to insist that only legislators can propose model bills at its meetings.

5. Amend the Constitution

In recent years, one of ALEC's top priorities has been to add a balanced budget amendment to the U.S. Constitution. And it will be a major focus of this month's meeting.

A balanced budget amendment is an idea that has been bouncing around for decades--even though it would cripple the federal government's ability to spend on earned benefit programs like Social Security, and block Congress from responding to economic downturns or natural disasters--but what is unique about ALEC's push is that they are trying to do it via an Article V Constitutional Convention.

Article V of the U.S. Constitution provides that thirty-four states (two-thirds) can trigger a convention to propose an amendment, which must then be ratified by 38 states (three-fourths). Although this seems like a tall order, in the past year over a dozen states have passed resolutions calling for an Article V convention, adding to at least twelve other states that enacted resolutions years ago. The proposal has been supported by Koch-backed groups like Americans for Prosperity and the National Federation of Independent Business (NFIB).

Key to the Article V push has been the "Jeffersonian Project," the 501(c)(4) group that ALEC formed in 2013 amidst complaints from Common Cause and CMD that ALEC was violating its 501(c)(3) charitable status by engaging in excessive lobbying. In order to deflect allegations of lobbying, the "Jeffersonian Project" is now used to urge legislators to pass ALEC model legislation, an activity that ALEC used to do directly.

This year, the Article V strategy dominates the agenda of ALEC's Task Force on Federalism and International Relations, with five presentations and two pieces of draft legislation. The task force's private sector chair is a representative of Americans for Tax Reform, the anti-tax group founded by Grover Norquist. And, there will be two separate ALEC-wide policy workshops on the Article V effort, as well as a reception and dinner titled "States Constitutionally Saving “The American Dream” Summit Via Balanced Budget Amendment Convention."
Throughout U.S. history, the Constitution has only been amended through a two-thirds majority vote in both houses of Congress on a specific amendment, which is then ratified by two-thirds of state legislatures. In contrast, the Article V strategy triggers a full constitutional convention, and it is unclear whether the delegates could be confined to only passing one amendment. This fear of a "runaway convention" has led critics on both the right and left to oppose the Article V strategy.

ALEC has tried to quell these fears through a companion bill declaring that delegates to a convention may not vote on other issues besides a balanced budget amendment. Yet, at least some amendment supporters want to open up the Article V process and amendment the constitution to address an array of issues, like limiting the Commerce Clause, banning international law in the U.S., and placing term limits on the Supreme Court, among other items from a right-wing wishlist.

The key driver of the broader Article V amendment effort is Citizens for Self-Governance (CSG), a group led by Tea Party Patriots co-founder Mark Meckler, and whose board includes Wisconsinite Eric O'Keefe. CSG, which receives most of its funding through foundations such as DonorsTrust that cloak their donors' identities, has also backed multiple lawsuits related to the "John Doe" investigation into coordination between Governor Walker's campaign and Wisconsin Club for Growth, where O'Keefe is a director.
CSG's Convention of States effort has been endorsed by Mike Huckabee (who will be addressing the ALEC conference) and also attracted support from the likes of Glenn Beck. CSG's "Compact for America" appears on the ALEC agenda with both a presentation and a model bill, and Meckler will also address the conference on July 24.

Another group pushing an Article V amendment is Compact for America, a Texas-based group advised by Nick Dranias, formerly of the Goldwater Institute, and chaired by former Goldwater chair Thomas C. Patterson. This group also is promoting a model bill at the ALEC meeting, and will hold a full breakout session on July 23.

Wisconsin State Rep. Chris Taylor attended a session on ALEC's Article V plans at the group's 2013 conference. When she expressed hesitation that the public would support the effort, she was told, "You really don’t need people to do this. You just need control over the legislature and you need money, and we have both."

6. Continue Fighting "Obamacare"

ALEC has long tried to undermine the 2010 federal Affordable Care Act. It produced the "State Legislators' Guide to Repealing Obamacare," and has promoted bills to try blocking the individual mandate in states, and to prohibit insurers from providing subsidies to low-income residents, and to reject the insurance “exchanges” where individuals can buy insurance (which would have had serious repercussions if the U.S. Supreme Court ruled differently in King v. Burwell).

Despite repeated failures to overturn the Affordable Care Act through Congress and the courts, ALEC is continuing to fight the law through the states.
At this month's meeting, the Health and Human Services Task Force will consider a bill to limit expansion of Medicaid benefits within the state, and the Tax and Fiscal Policy Task Force will have a resolution on the purported negative impact of Medicaid expansion under the healthcare law. The task force will also consider a resolution opposing federal "maintenance of effort" requirements, like those in Obamacare and also with education funding.

7. Fighting to Protect Dark Money

After spending hundreds of millions of undisclosed funds on state and federal elections, ALEC's corporate members will also demand that state legislators preserve their "right" to anonymously spend money on politics and buy influence in state legislatures.

A July 23 workshop titled "Dark Money Debate: What Lawmakers Need to Know about the First Amendment and Anonymous Political Speech" will promote the idea that transparency in elections is a bad thing. David Keating of the Center for Competitive Politics and Jon Riches of the Goldwater Institute are listed as presenters.

It is little surprise that corporate interests would peddle secrecy to the hundreds of Republican state legislators at ALEC.

ALEC's funders, like the billionaire Koch brothers, have spent millions in "dark money"--electoral spending that evades donor disclosure laws--in recent years, secret spending which has increased exponentially since the U.S. Supreme Court's 2010 Citizens United decision.

Disclosure of electoral spending has widespread support among the public, and it still has support among many Republican state lawmakers. ALEC, it seems, is trying to change that.

This isn't ALEC's first foray into this issue. Its 2010 "Resolution in Support of Citizens United" opposes both the disclosure and shareholder participation endorsed by the majority in Citizens United. In 2011, ALEC lobbied legislators in states like New York urging them to reject a proposal requiring corporations get shareholder approval for political spending. And at ALEC's meeting last December, ALEC held a similarly themed workshop called "Playing the Shame Game: A Campaign that Threatens Corporate Free Speech."

Editor’s note: CMD's Mary Bottari contributed to this article.

Brendan Fischer is general counsel for the Center for Media and Democracy, publisher of PR Watch.

Friday, July 17, 2015

Trump Is Such A Liar That Politifact Is Worried About Becoming ‘The Trump Channel’


Addicting Info

Trump Is Such A Liar That Politifact Is Worried About Becoming ‘The Trump Channel’

Author: July 16, 2015 1:33 pm
 Trump Is Such A Liar That Politifact Is Worried About Becoming ‘The Trump Channel’
 
Donald Trump is the worst America has to offer. He has zero class and not a single redeeming quality. Every time he opens his mouth he embarrasses himself, his party and his country. Extraterrestrials will surely use him as the last straw in deciding not to make contact with humans.

Yet this man, this absolute disgrace to humanity, is somehow polling at the top of the Republican field. It’s really not that difficult to figure out. Trump’s blowhard style and penchant for outright lying to his followers will get him far with the modern conservative base.

They want to hear all about his phony statistics, his massive wealth and his success as a reality TV star. Of course they do. The modern Republican base are a bunch of Donald Trump wannabes. They want enough money that they can crap on the poor all day long. They want enough public exposure that they can say the dumbest of things and still be taken seriously by other numbskulls.

Donald Trump is the perfect hero for the “patriots” of the new conservative movement.

But Trump’s popularity isn’t winning the hearts of the people at Politifact. A trusted fact-checker, Politifact has been busy since the start of Trump’s campaign debunking the mound of garbage spewed forth from his mouth.
Trump’s statements about fellow Republican Jeb Bush, the Obamacare website, Mexico sending us their rapists, all of those ridiculous things have rated anywhere from mostly false to “pants on fire.” Here’s a summary of what Politifact has dealt with from the Donald:


Notice the zero next to “true.” Nothing Trump has said that’s been researched by Politifact is true. Nothing.

PolitiFact editor Angie Drobnic Holan told the Washington Post:
“Donald Trump has been making a lot of comments that get into the headlines and he’s been saying a lot of things that sound wrong, and that’s a combination that attracts fact-checkers. I don’t want to turn this whole sit into the Trump Channel.”
Trump’s campaign has apparently officially given up bothering to try making their candidate sound truthful. Holan noted that in the beginning of the run, there was some contact with Trump’s campaign when they tried fact-checking his stupidity, but lately they haven’t responded at all.

And still his numbers grow, his popularity increases, and his nose gets longer. It certainly will be interesting to watch all of this blow up in his face when the real campaigning and debating happens.

Featured image via screen capture





















Tuesday, May 12, 2015

ALEC’s big lie: Scott Walker’s pseudo-science, austerity without end, and the truth about right-wing governors and the economy


SALON




ALEC’s big lie: Scott Walker’s pseudo-science, austerity without end, and the truth about right-wing governors and the economy

Republicans don't believe in global warming science, but love unscientific tax "science" that benefits the rich



ALEC's big lie: Scott Walker's pseudo-science, austerity without end, and the truth about right-wing governors and the economyScott Walker (Credit: AP/Lefteris Pitarakis)
 
Republican governors’ woeful economic records are crippling what would normally be the strongest chance the party has to capture the White House. Historically, the statehouse-to-White-House pathway is far more viable than the route through the Senate, yet GOP governors’ records offer little to run on in a general election. Healthy state-level growth is—at least traditionally—a basic resume requirement.

I have argued that the GOP’s perceived advantage on the economy is entirely a matter of illusion, citing Erik Zuesse’s “They’re Not Even Close: The Democratic vs. Republican Economic Records,” 1910-2010, a point that Salon’s Sean McElwee has since reinforced, citing “11 reasons why America does worse under the GOP.” But the national picture is not the only place to look for such evidence. The failure of GOP ideology on the state level deserves further scrutiny as well, particularly with so many governors and ex-governors in the race. The 2012 study “Selling Snake Oil To The States,” which demolished the tax-slashing prescription package offered by ALEC (the American Legislative Exchange Council) and right-wing economist Arthur Laffer, helps to define the parameters of GOP state-level economic policy.

But ALEC is only one of several such organizations, and Peter Fisher, who co-authored the “Snake Oil” study, has studied their work as a whole, and found it dismally deficient. In 2005, he authored a book published by the Economic Policy Institute, “Grading Places: What Do the Business Climate Rankings Really Tell Us?,” then in 2013, Good Jobs First published his updated analyis, which covered four state rankings still being published, as well as two more sophisticated guides which at least try to simplistically model actual tax costs—though with severely limited success.

The four indexes are the The ALEC-Laffer Economic Competitiveness Index; the Tax Foundation’s State Business Tax Climate Index; the Beacon Hill Institute’s State Competitiveness Report; and the Small Business and Entrepreneurship Council’s U.S. Business Policy Index. The last combines a broad range of 46 factors—but only 12 dealing with tax progressivity actually matter in the rankings—just one indication of how much confusion reigns in this field. Another indication: states ranking high in one index often rank low in another. Most importantly, there’s no relation between scoring well and actual economic performance. The entire “business climate” cottage industry which drives so much of the GOP’s state-level economic agenda is nothing but baseless pseudo-science.

Thus, ironically, at the same time that Republicans are at war with actual climate science, they are routinely invoking economic articles of faith, reflected in the bogus field of “business climate” studies which directly guides their policies on the state level, and defines their economic outlook more generally. It’s a commonplace for Republicans like John Boehner to profess ignorance regarding climate science, while pretending to know that “every proposal that has come out of this administration to deal with climate change involves hurting our economy and killing American jobs.” Not only have recently emerging fossil fuel industry troubles, coupled with renewable advances, which I wrote about recently, made Boehner’s job-killing claims look foolish on their face, the entire background for such economic self-assurance—reflected both in conservative orthodoxy and far too much of “conventional wisdom”—turns out to be nothing but hot air.

In the introduction to “Grading Places,” Fisher writes, “The six reports we review in detail all purport to measure the competitiveness of a state for business activity, and all emphasize the importance of taxes. Three focus exclusively on some measure of state taxes on business; the others include nontax factors but state tax policy still plays a prominent role in their calculations.”

But as Fisher later notes, the reality is that tax policy plays a decidedly minor role in most business decision-making, because taxes themselves are a relatively minor cost: “[A]ll state and local taxes on businesses combined (including corporate and individual income taxes, sales taxes, plus local property taxes) represent only about 1.8 percent of total business costs on average for all states.” That’s clearly not a dominant consideration, but the kinds of taxes these groups focus on represent an even smaller share: “Corporate income taxes, in turn, are only about 9.5 percent of that 1.8 percent, or 0.17 percent, according to one estimate.”

There’s even a good case that these “pro-business” groups are exactly the opposite of what they purport to be, given how the needs of established big businesses and the far more numerous small startups diverge. “In fact, a state tax system that relies heavily on progressive income taxes is probably the most supportive of new business and innovation,” Fisher writes. “Start-ups and young firms typically lose money, and owe no income taxes as a result. By contrast, firms must pay sales and property taxes no matter what their level of profitability, so states that depend more heavily on those taxes create a heavier burden on start-ups and young businesses in those critical formative years.”
Even if the role of taxes weren’t inflated and misrepresented, profound problems would still remain with these rating guides. “An examination of the four most prominent ‘business climate’ ratings of state tax systems finds them to be deeply flawed and of no value to informing state policy,” Fisher says in the executive summary, before ticking through a list of glaring flaws, starting with perhaps the most fundamental: “They produce state rankings that bear little relation to actual taxes paid in one state versus another.” Astonishing, perhaps, but when interviewed, Fisher quickly confirmed it. “These are purporting to measure business climate, or in some cases, more narrowly, business tax climate. But even when they’re just narrowly focused on business tax climate, they’re not measuring what businesses actually pay,” he said.  They often total up “points” for various features of the tax code—number and width of brackets, for example—rather than looking directly at actual tax bills paid.

It’s not rocket science, Fisher pointed out. “There are fairly simple ways of coming up with a rough average of how much business tax are in one state for another. You just look at business taxes collected as a percent of the state GDP for example or personal income.” But that’s not what the “business climate” indexes do. “They often bear so little correlation that you really wonder what they are measuring,” Fisher said. “If their goal is to measure how much businesses paying what state versus another, why don’t they just rely on one of these other approaches instead cobbling together this index number that turns out to not being much?”

As already mentioned, the U.S. Business Policy Index combines a broad range of 46 factors, but only 12 dealing with tax progressivity actually matter in the rankings. This little tidbit deserves more scrutiny for the insight it provides into how this field of “study” actually works, and what a real pseudo-science looks like.  More specifically, the report states, “When the 12 measures of progressive taxes are combined, the state scores range from zero (in Wyoming, with no individual or corporate income taxes and no estate or inheritance tax) to 73.4 (in California).” In sharp contrast, “The ranges between the lowest and highest scores on the other categories is a fraction of this amount, ranging from just 3.7 points for the labor policy variables to 11.8 points for government regulation.” Indeed, a chart showing how states score from lowest to highest shows virtually no visible trend for any of the other categories.

In real social science—like all science—a major goal is to isolate the smallest number of factors that produce a given outcome. First you eliminate the extraneous factors, then you can study how the factors that matter interact with one another. That’s how knowledge gets accumulated over time. There’s nothing wrong with studying 46 factors in the first place, as the USBPI does, but there’s a big problem with continuing to study them when most of them turn out to be irrelevant. Of course, in this case, nothing real is being measured—only an abstract aggregate “score”.  But the principle remains the same: factors that only contribute noise to the score should be eliminated from calculating it. And yet, the USBPI remains overloaded with 34 items and all of three categories which are minor distractions at best, if not entirely irrelevant.

The reason for this should be obvious: the USBPI was created for political purposes, to serve multiple related, but not identical, agendas.  The one that really matters is promoting regressive taxation, so the rest turn out not to really matter. But saying so outright would clash with the political agenda of crafting a broader appeal. So the index continues to include a large majority of irrelevant items. It goes without saying that nothing remotely similar happens with climate science.  In climate science, tests of statistical significance are run all the time, and factors that fail to make the cut are eliminated from causal accounts—at least until some new evidence for them can be found.

While four of the measures are simple indexes, two are a bit more sophisticated, examples of what are called “represenative firm models,” prepared by brand-name accounting firms: the Council on State Taxation’s Competitiveness of State and Local Business Taxes on New Investment, and the Tax Foundation’s Location Matters.  As Fisher wrote, “These mathematical models allow for more complexity and nuance because they acknowledge that different companies and facilities vary greatly in how they interact with tax codes and they are aimed at measuring how tax systems impact plant expansions or relocations.”  But he went on to say “Unfortunately, both models have serious flaws and fail to take full advantage of the methodology,” and elsewhere, he wrote, “both are weakened by simplifying assumptions that lead to misleading results.” When I interviewed him, Fisher was even more critical of what they had done.

“I probably shouldn’t have used the term mathematical model, when I think about it,” Fisher said, “because all they’ve really done in these other studies is reduce the state corporate income tax form, and property tax law to spreadsheet formulas…. It’s like tax preparation software to you buy.”  Put simply, the measures “model” the tax bill paid by “representative firms” in each state—with some glaring omissions (COST ignores tax incentives, for example)—but not the economic conditions in which they would do business, as the term “model” would seem to imply. The COST model “assumes every facility sells five percent of its output in-state, whether it is located in, say, California or North Dakota,” for example. Out-of-state sales levels are also set arbitrarily and unrealistically as well.

Still, compared to the four index measures, “that is a much better yardstick of what businesses are actually going to pay,” Fisher said.  While the tax codes may not be completely modeled, and the business assumptions may be unrealistic in some ways, it still looks much better than how the index are created.

As Fisher described the typical process of analyzing tax features, “You just take each one by itself and add them up. So you say ‘We’re going to give you five points for having only two tax brackets. We’re going to give you three points for having a top rate under 10%. We’re going to give you one point for not having a state minimum wage.’ Then you add the points up, and you might have 50, 75, 100 different tax features, and you just add them all up and you’ve got a number. Well, that’s pretty meaningless number, and it’s pretty arbitrary how you decide to weight those different features.”  Suddenly, modeling a “representative firm” that sells as much in state in California as it does in North Dakota starts to look pretty good—even though it’s still far from being realistic.
These models, though, are still far from the standard form of analysis used in social science.

This doesn’t mean that indexes are necessarily misguided. Fisher goes on to say, “To a significant degree, the legitimacy of an index depends on how well it mimics a more sophisticated statistical approach.” However, “As we shall see, the indexes reviewed here fail this test.”

Another fundamental problem is the very existence of a “business climate,” as a meaningful concept, which Fisher also remarks on:
It is not clear that the very concept of “business climate” or “competitiveness index” for an entire state or metro area makes sense to begin with. Charles Skoro has argued that “the usefulness of the business climate concept depends on the existence of a set of indicators that are measurable, that have substantial effects on business outcomes, and that are truly generic—they influence business activity in a more or less uniform manner regardless of industry, region, or time period.”
As with the more limited example of the USBPI, there may be strong political reasons why talk about a “business climate” has a broad appeal, but that doesn’t tell us anything about whether such general “business climates” actually exist.  What may be good for one particular industry—at least in the short run—may not be very helpful for businesses in general, and could even be disadvantageous for some other industries. There is simply no advance guarantee, one way or the other.

Fisher continues:
Others have made similar arguments: that the factors important to location and expansion decisions are industry-specific, and that the conditions conducive to growth can vary tremendously within a state.
They also argue—and we agree—that metropolitan regions, not states, are the meaningful unit of competition for business investment decisions. New York City bears little resemblance to Buffalo; the same is true for El Paso and Houston and for San Jose and San Bernardino.
In short, the entire enterprise may simply be ill-conceived. On the other hand, there are some kinds of policies which do make broad-based sense—but they reflect a much broader mindset than just thinking about “business climate.” Elsewhere, Fisher writes, “In the long run of economic history, the only way to achieve broadly shared prosperity is to increase productivity. Only if more goods and services are produced per capita, can more goods and services can be consumed per capita (or the work week shortened without reducing the standard of living).”

He goes on to identify four ways this can be achieved: First, capital investments “make the economy more productive,” second, technological advances “increase the efficiency of production,” create “new uses of existing resources” or “new products and services,” third, “investments in ‘human capital’” (education and training) make labor more productive, and fourth, an economy’s overall productivity is maximized via full employment and “a labor force that remains healthy and on the job.” Such are the prescriptions for making an economy as productive as possible. But what makes sense for society as a whole is not necessarily what makes sense for individual actors, particularly greedy, selfish, sociopathic ones. And that’s arguably the whole purpose behind the “business climate” racket—to bamboozle the public into seeing the world the way that greedy, selfish corporate sociopaths do.

One final point drives home just how bogus “business climate” studies are: their lack of development in response to criticism over time. Once again, the contrast with real climate science is instructive. In the climate modeling field, there has been long-term interaction between model-building and criticisms, most notably focused on important elements of the physical climate system which were missing from climate models at various stages.  Over time, more elements were added to climate models, their integration has improved, and the models have become more fine-grained, producing specific outputs for smaller and smaller geographic areas. All these have been clearly recognizable signs of progress,. Researchers have also undertaken significant studies relying on the results of a whole suite of models, reflecting the fact that there are reliable similarities in their results. This is what a successful model-development process looks like.
In contrast, Fisher said, “I see very little change in these models over the years…. In fact, the accompanying text in these reports hardly changes year-to-year. So, for example, the latest Tax Foundation report that came out in December last year still has exactly the same wording attacking my 2005 first edition of Grading Places. So they haven’t even bothered to note the second edition. They haven’t acknowledged any of the specific criticisms of their model, really.”

The indexes themselves aren’t improved, in part because it would interfere with their propaganda usefulness, Fisher believes. “The measures stay the same. I think, in part, because when they issue a new one they want to say, ‘Well look what North Carolina jumped 15 places in the ranking this year. Why?  Because they cut all these taxes.’” That sort of comparison would be harder to make if the index itself were to change. “So in part I think it’s because they’re not really serious attempts to measure something meaningful. They have a policy agenda in mind, and the way they constructed it serves that policy agenda, and they have no real incentive to change. Part of it is because they just want to have a consistent one from year-to-year, they don’t want to admit, probably, that there’s anything wrong with the earlier ones, and they want to be able to make year-to-year comparisons.”

In short, there’s nothing serious involved in what they do. “They are basically recipes for state fiscal austerity, for cutting government spending across the board, and reducing taxes on business, but also on individuals,” Fisher summarized. That’s what they are designed to advocate for, so why bother with anything else?

Speaking specifically about ALEC’s index, he noted, “They acknowledged no positive role for government whatsoever. There’s nothing the government does that’s important in promoting economic growth, it only enters negatively. So, the more government employees you have, the worse your ranking. It doesn’t matter what they’re doing. They could be elementary school teachers, firefighters, it doesn’t matter, the more you have, the worse your economy is going to be according to these measures.”

It is, in short, a rationale for austerity without end—which simply cannot work. “It’s largely states that are responsible for education at all levels, not the federal government. It’s largely states they have responsibility—states and localities—have responsibility for investing in infrastructure. You can’t have an economy without a transportation system, without public utilities, water and sewage, high-speed Internet in rural areas, everybody acknowledges they’re important. And so, when you undercut the funding source for those kinds of public investment, you’re undercutting the ability of the state to increase productivity and support economic growth in the long run.”

But that’s the playbook that state-level Republicans have embraced, legislators and governors alike. Which is just one more reason why today’s crop of presidential wannabes are so weak on the economy. The political press won’t tell you so, of course. But it’s a profound vulnerability just waiting to be exploited—and it’s only likely to get worse as different GOP governors and ex-governors compete with one another in the GOP primary.

Fisher leaves us with one final thought worth stressing—the short-term strategies these measures push are, in the long-run, ultimately destructive of income growth and wealth-creation:
Increase in productivity is what is required for increase in incomes. And what we see with these indexes is they’re promoting, almost exclusively, a competitive strategy of your state capturing a bigger share of investment, this really what it’s about. How can you, in effect, steal capital investments from your neighbors? That does nothing for the national economy, to have states competing for investment that’s going to occur somewhere anyway. What it does is undercut their ability to fund that traditional state role in supporting economic growth through investments in education, infrastructure, and even health.
In short, it’s not a prescription for growing an economy of the future. But some version of it or another will be the GOP vision for 2016.


Paul Rosenberg is a California-based writer/activist, senior editor for Random Lengths News, and a columnist for Al Jazeera English. Follow him on Twitter at @PaulHRosenberg.

Thursday, January 1, 2015

In 2014 America Abandoned Its Constitution And Devolved Into a Fascist Theocracy




more from Rmuse
 
Thursday, January, 1st, 2015, 9:48 am



Share on Tumblr
constitution-burning


It is usual at the end of another calendar year to look hopefully at the New Year, but at this point, and judging by the events of 2014, there is very little to look forward to in America in 2015. In fact, it is getting extremely difficult to look ahead at the coming year with anything other than dread and despair as America devolves into a theocratic, racist, and fascist police state that the government cannot, and apparently will not, even attempt to stop. It is not that 2014 was devoid of good news; quite the contrary.  But no amount of jobs, Wall Street profits, economic growth, or falling gas prices can counterbalance the distress Republicans, racists, and religious Supreme Court justices have wrought on this sad nation with no end, or hope, in sight.

First, it is noteworthy that the only good developments of 2014 were at the hands of President Obama and his executive actions; particularly acting on the existential issue of “global” climate change and his landmark agreement with China. The President’s action on immigration enforcement was long overdue, but in his defense he did wait patiently for House Republicans to adopt, or at least consider, the bipartisan Senate immigration reform bill to no avail. What his action did was reveal why 2015, like the past six years, will be depressing for Americans who will watch a Republican-controlled Congress waste taxpayer time and money in a crusade to undo a valid executive order the GOP has deemed unconstitutional; despite the conservative Roberts Court already ruled the President was well within his constitutional authority like every Republican president since Dwight D. Eisenhower. But that is the price Americans have to pay for living in a nation with a party so steeped in racial animus for a  Black President that they have deemed his entire Presidency is unconstitutional.

Maybe more than anything, seeing the U.S. Constitution treated like an afterthought, if not a worthless comic book, by conservatives, evangelicals, law enforcement, Republicans, and the Supreme Court is all the proof a reasonable human being needs to realize America is doomed. Republicans claim anything President Obama does in unconstitutional at the same time they attempted to pass legislation authorizing approval to build a foreign corporation’s tar sand pipeline across America. That decision is the exclusive right of the Executive Department and yet, one of the first actions a Republican Congress will undertake to repay their Koch debt will be patently unconstitutional and no-one will dare utter a complaint any more than they will over the Republican drive to enforce Vatican rules banning all forms of birth control with personhood legislation; more on that in another article.

Republicans in state after state were hastily passing legislation abolishing other Americans’ 14th Amendment rights due to their adherence to bastardized American Christianity and empowerment by the Vatican contingent on the Supreme Court. History will show that it was in 2014 that 5 conservative Catholics on the Highest Court in the land deconstructed the religious clauses in the 1st Amendment to the Constitution to expedite evangelical Christians and the United States Council of Catholic Bishops’ ascendance to wield ironclad authority over the religious freedom of the rest of the population. Through it all, not one politician had the courage or conviction to inform the American people that every dirty attempt to deny women the right to make their own health choices, or gays to marry the person they love, was founded in an archaic religious text because they were, and still are, terrified of committing the mortal sin of speaking out against or opposing theocracy. Speaking of mortal sins, the past six months have revealed that there is no greater sin than speaking out against out-of-control and murderous law enforcement officials doing their due diligence to eviscerate the Constitutional protections afforded all Americans.

If racist police officers were not gunning down unarmed African Americans with impunity  ending their Constitutional right to life with approval of the judicial system, they were threatening Americans opposed to fascist police tactics complete with battlefield gear. Instead of supporting and defending the U.S. Constitution, they took great pleasure in denying Americans their First Amendment rights of free speech and free assembly. All, by the way, with approval and support of Republicans and conservatives as blatantly racist as the police abusing African Americans whether civilians or fellow police officers.  Law enforcement was also complicit in aiding and abetting, through direct support, a seditious  white man and his well-armed Oath Keeper, Constitutional Sheriffs and Police Officers Association (CSPOA) militia intent on initiating a second revolution; with impunity and ardent support of conservative media and Republicans with no more regard for the Constitution as they do African Americans, poor people, elderly Americans, Veterans, or children.

America may have been an exceptional nation at one time, but the country began its downward spiral thirty years ago when Republicans and conservatives decided, and convinced many Americans, their mortal enemy was the federal government; a federal government created by the U.S. Constitution. Now, that very Constitution has all but been rendered null-and-void either by government fear of opposing sedition, or an all-powerful evangelical movement with avid support of the conservative Catholics on the Supreme Court.

Throughout history, other peoples have sat idly by and watched their freedoms eroded, and finally abolished, by fascist religious, corporate, and military-style enforcers, and America is rapidly heading in the same direction with the same results. One would like to say this country is at a crossroads, or nearing a tipping point, of which there is no return, but according to what this nation has suffered throughout 2014 at the hands of fascist police, armed militias, evangelical fanatics, and a theocratic Supreme Court, the scales are tipped. America is on the same course as 1930s Nazi Germany and the Koch brothers are more than happy to fund this country into oblivion. If 2014 is any indication, 2015 is not going to be a Happy New Year.




In 2014 America Abandoned Its Constitution And Devolved Into a Fascist Theocracy was written by Rmuse for PoliticusUSA.
© PoliticusUSA, Thu, Jan 1st, 2015 — All Rights Reserved

Connection Revealed: Eat Fast Food, Vote Republican


Who Hijacked Our Country

 

Tuesday, December 23, 2014

Connection Revealed: Eat Fast Food, Vote Republican


Fast/processed/convenience “food” not only has the health risks we already know about — obesity, heart disease, diabetes, et al.  In addition, too much fast food affects your brain.  And not in a good way.

According to a recent study published in Clinical Pediatrics:  “Our findings provide evidence that eating fast food is linked to another problem: poorer academic outcomes.”

That's sugarcoating-speak for “It makes you dumb.  Upid-stay.”

Think there's a connection between the mass overconsumption of fast food, and the fact that millions of voters keep getting conned into voting against their own interests?  Let's have a look:

1. Tens of millions of Americans have spent years — decades — clogging their brains with boatloads of high fructose corn syrup, pink slime, white flour, and hundreds of “additives” your high school chemistry teacher never heard of.

2. Tens of millions of Americans believe:
A) Clean air, drinkable water and renewable energy sources are just phony excuses for Barack Hussein Osama, the U.N. and the Trilateral Commission to Seize Our Property;

B) The aforementioned villains from the previous sentence are also planning to take away our guns the minute we let our guard down.

C)  The economy is being strangled by too many cumbersome regulations.  As soon as we eliminate these intrusive laws that coddle workers, consumers and the environment, millions of new jobs will be created so fast our heads will be spinning.

D) The Great Crash of 2008 was caused by labor unions, non-profit organizations, too many Wall Street regulations which straitjacketed the banks so they couldn't do their jobs, and millions of greedy homeowners who just couldn't wait to buy a house they couldn't afford so they'd get foreclosed and lose everything they had.

E) There's no such thing as global warming; it's just God hugging us closer.   Etc.

Connect the dots.


posted by Tom Harper @ 12:49 AM

10 of the Worst GOP Outrages of 2014



From rancher Cliven Bundy to the war on voting rights, this list will make you tear your hair out.


With 2014 coming to a close, it's worth remembering all the stuff we want to leave behind as we embrace the new year. Among these things are a whole host of outrages from the Republican Party. We present 10 of the worst and most outrageous political acts by the GOP this year:

1. Exploiting Police Deaths To Attack Democrats: Shortly after the tragic killings of two police officers in New York City, former Republican mayor Rudy Giuliani used the murders to accuse current mayor Bill de Blasio and President Obama of inciting the murders by criticizing police.

2. Astroturfing Minority Support: Rather than alter their policies to better the lives of racial minorities, several Republican candidatesdecided to use stock images of African Americans in their campaign advertisements to create the impression that the party doesn't have a white Christian male problem of narrowing support from diverse groups.

3. Promoting Bigotry Under Guise of Religious Freedom: Republicans in state legislatures nationwide promoted bills they claim were designed to advance “religious freedom” but were really about the right for businesses to use religion as a shield for refusing services to marginalized groups like gay Americans. In most states, these bills failed, but one did pass the Michigan House though it was not signed into law by the Senate.

4. Waging War On Voting Rights: As part of their 2014 push, Republicans across the country continued to push for disenfranchisement-promoting voter ID laws and attacks on early voting. One Georgia county even killed early voting because officials worried it was “just a way to wring out every last vote.” It wasn't all bad news, though. In Montana voters chose to keep election-day registration.

5. Holding Government Hostage to Deregulate Wall Street: In a last-minute showdown over a government spending bill, the GOP inserted a provision to deregulate a section of the Dodd-Frank rules on Wall Street. Despite a defiant stand by Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) the GOP's hostage-taking succeeded as Senate Democrats folded to their demands.

6. Calling For Crippling Flight Bans to Combat Ebola: Despite protests from virtually the entire medical community, GOP pols exploited panic about Ebola to call for flight bans to all of West Africa. Rep. Louie Gohmert (R-TX) even said Obama was trying to import Ebola into the U.S.

7. Defending An Extremist Who Squatted on Federal Property:Although much of the right is mum about today's police brutality protests, they championed the cause of cattle rancher Cliven Bundy, whose fans took up arms to keep the federal government from removing him from federal property. Leading Republican politicians such as senators Dean Heller (NV) and Rand Paul (KY) defended Bundy's revolt.

8. Continuing to Deny Climate Change: The GOP continued its long history of resisting any change to climate policy. Louisiana state Rep. Lenar Whitney said the whole thing was a hoax and “the greatest deception in the history of mankind.” A long string of Republican pols responded to questions about global warming by saying “I'm not a scientist,” somehow believing this exempted them from having to give an opinion on the matter.

9. Electing the Senate's Newest Right-Wing Extremist: In Iowa, Republicans succeeded in electing Joni Ernst to the Senate. She touts United Nations conspiracies to take Iowan farmland, believes the president is a dictator, wants the federal minimum wage to be abolished, and thinks states can just nullify federal laws they dislike.

10. Trying Tt Prolong Our 50-Year Embargo on Cuba: While President Obama earned broad bipartisan praise and approval from the public and some GOP lawmakers for his Cuba move, some on the right lined up to pile on him, saying he rewarded tyranny and was practicing appeasement. For these Republicans, 50 years of a bad policy wasn't enough.

What were your top GOP outrages of 2014? What do you think we will have to endure next year?

Zaid Jilani is an AlterNet contributing writer. Follow @zaidjilani on Twitter.